Monday, 24 August 2015

The Tuesday Truth


The Story so Far
by Zoe Gascoyne
 

In April 2013 the then Lord Chancellor, Chris Grayling, announced plans to cut criminal legal aid by 17.5%. He recognised that the profession could not sustain such a cut and so he sought to enforce market consolidation. His first plan was to introduce PCT and remove client choice.  The profession reacted angrily and 16,000 consultation responses were submitted. 

 A second consultation was commenced and notwithstanding the opposition the government announced Two Tier, forced consolidation which would see most firms put out of business.  The CLSA and LCCSA embarked upon not one but two Judicial Reviews in opposition to Two Tier.

On the 10th June 2015 the Lord Chancellor announced that he was to proceed with a further 8.75% cut to fees before any consolidation.  The same statutory instrument introducing the cut contains further cuts to be implemented in January 2016. The CLSA and LCCSA made immediate requests to meet with the Lord Chancellor to discuss their concerns. These requests were not responded to and so solicitors across the country took an unprecedented stand by refusing to work under the new rates. Merseyside were the first to take action publicly declaring that they wanted engagement with the Lord Chancellor and the MoJ. Many areas followed suit.

On the 23rd July, after just over three weeks of action and seven letters from the CLSA and LCCSA, the Lord Chancellor met with the committees. Discussions were held in relation to the cuts and two tier and the associations made their position and opposition to both very clear.

A paper was submitted to the MoJ for consideration and a second meeting to discuss various matters was held on the 3rd August 2015. After a ninety minute meeting it was agreed that the associations would provide the MoJ with examples of savings that could be made which might in turn negate the need to cut to legal aid rates for a three month period.

The Lord Chancellor has made it perfectly clear what he is and isn't willing to consider in the initial stages of negotiations. The Lord Chancellor and the MoJ state that they are committed to two tier unless an alternative could be produced to be implemented within the time scale. They maintain that any suspension of the cut would be for a period of three months if the savings could be made elsewhere.  The associations have made their ongoing position very clear to the MoJ during every meeting. On behalf of the profession we continue to seek a permanent suspension of the cut and we continue to challenge Two Tier.  We must however acknowledge what the Lord Chancellor has set out and we view this as being the start of longer term engagement.

On the 11th August 2015 a third meeting took place.  The meeting was to discuss the four proposals for savings with the MoJ and LAA.  An assurance had already been given that any proposals made would not simply be banked. The proposals were well received and it was acknowledged that they were practical and could potentially amount to savings within the system to make up the short fall for suspending the cut. Since that meeting there has been telephone communication this week on two separate occasions between the associations and the MoJ. It is clear that the MoJ are taking the suggestions seriously and have embarked upon some number crunching before any final decisions can be made.

The associations have made considered decisions at every stage. There have been assurances made by the MoJ that since the last meeting there has been no unnecessary delay. The proposals made were serious and worthy of consideration. The calculations will take a little time given the information required across the board.  In the meantime a decision has been taken that the action should be suspended. This decision has been made as a consequence of a number of factors including information made available to those negotiating. We take the views of the profession seriously and we acknowledge the difficult financial constraints that the action was imposing upon an already fragile profession. We also recognise that there are members of the profession who have sought to gain whilst action is being taken.

At this stage we make it perfectly clear that this is far from over. The negotiations are on going and we expect a response within the next two weeks. Once that response has been received we will be in a position to move forwards in one way or another. We take the view that this is a process that needs to be dealt with in stages.

In the meantime we have embarked upon a fresh start with the new leadership of the CBA and we continue with our fight to ensure a sustainable criminal justice system for those who need it and for the profession themselves.

The CLSA and LCCSA consist entirely of criminal legal aid practitioners.  There will be no deals and no capitulation.  We understand and acknowledge the frustrations of many but we ask for an understanding that we cannot broadcast every detail across social media. There has been a solid fight by the associations against two tier and the cuts for two years, our opposition remains just as strong.  There is currently a bid withdrawal survey organised by the LCCSA which remains open until the 28th August. We understand that there are some who call for a continuation of the action however the suspension allows for a period of reflection.  To allow a response to the negotiations this far and to consider what steps may be required in the future.  There are times when action is necessary and there are times when negotiation should be allowed to take place with clean hands.

Over the last two years the CLSA and LCCSA have organised numerous rallies and demonstrations. We have consulted MP's and spoken to the press. We have written open letters. We have raised funds for legal proceedings. We have attended meetings and organised meetings. We have taken legal advice and we have united a previously fragmented profession.  We have provided alternatives and we are negotiating. We have fought long and hard for two years and we remain staunch in our opposition. We have not given up. The were many who said that the action would never happen and they were wrong. There are many saying that we have waved the white flag and they too are wrong.

 

 

 

     

Monday, 17 August 2015

The Tuesday Truth


Magistrates are in revolt over what I will refer to in this blog as “Grayling’s Parting Gift” the Criminal Courts Charge. Over 20 have resigned in protest. The charges vary from the Magistrates’ Court and Crown Court, they are mandatory and not means tested.

It is, of course, likely to provide a perverse incentive to some innocent defendants to plead guilty because of the risk of the hugely disproportionate court charge if they are wrongly convicted.   These increases are consistent with a pattern of massive court fee increases in the civil courts including employment tribunals.

If you plead guilty to say a burglary in the Crown Court the court charge is £900.  Interestingly enough the legal aid fee payable to the litigator and advocate in such a case is likely to be less, probably in the region of approximately £700 + VAT, the litigator’s element less than £200.

If the defendant is in custody it is likely that for the litigator’s £200 they will have represented the defendant in the Magistrates Court, possibly prepared a Crown Court bail application, visited the defendant in custody on at least two occasions, and liaised with counsel and the Crown, all for substantially less than the defendant will have to pay in relation to an unmeritorious mandatory non-means tested charge.  As defence lawyers we, of course, welcome the outcry from Magistrates over the court charge, but quite frankly wish that they could also extend their protest to the equally appalling legal aid cuts and reforms.   After all they as much as anyone else witness the deterioration in the administration of justice every day before them and it is perhaps time that all stakeholders in this creaking justice system had the courage to stand up and say “no more”.

This isn’t about politics, it isn’t about the judiciary becoming involved in a political debate, it is about the delivery of a fair and robust justice system.  Every Judge and Magistrate up and down the country is charged with this duty and indeed has sworn on oath that they will protect the rule of law in their courtroom, yet as the system unravels their voice remains silent.

Criminal legal aid lawyers, solicitors and barristers have taken protest action since 1 July 2015. There has been engagement by the LCCSA and CLSA with the leadership of the criminal Bar and the Big Firm group.   The two-tier contract system due to be launched in January represents a huge threat to both solicitors and barristers.   Fees across the board for all the work solicitors do,  in the police stations, Magistrates’ Court and Crown Court, have been substantially slashed following the introduction of these new contracts.  Not by 8.75%, not by 17 ½ %, but by much more. Further swingeing cuts follow in January to the LGF scheme and before that in October fixed fees for VHCC cases will be introduced.

When will people wake up and start realising what is coming?   For a guilty plea in the Crown Court to an offence of burglary, the overall fee reduction will be 52%.   Many of the reductions to these fees are over 20 and 30%, with greater percentage reductions on not guilty trials.    If you plead not guilty to a serious sexual offence and the page count is in the region of 200 pages, the fee for preparing the trial which will inevitably be defence led and will involve taking very detailed instructions on a complainant’s allegations, finding witnesses and pursuing unused material relating to events that took place many years ago will be £917.17, a reduction of 38.22%. 

Examples such as the above have been rehearsed time and time again, but still many people do not get it.  The Government’s attitude is that duty contracts will deliver economies of scale, so that firms can afford to prepare cases for the fees that will be on  offer from January 2016. Can this be right? Can firms survive on mythical swings and roundabouts? What about quality legal advice?  What about dealing with the vulnerable?  What about a profession where liberty and reputation are the key words being treated appropriately with respect?  What about a Lord Chancellor who acknowledges the contribution of solicitors?

Again, all of the above has been rehearsed time and time again.  The Independent Bar stand to lose a great deal by two-tier.  Advocates’ fees remain the same.   To try to rebalance the books firms of solicitors will need to cover more Higher Court work in-house either by using Higher Court advocates or recruiting barristers from the Independent Bar.

The leadership of the Bar say if you really want to kill off two-tier then all firms should withdraw their bids.  However, although the LCCSA has launched such a bid withdrawal survey and the CLSA are considering their position this is not the only answer in town.  

It is an appalling analogy so forgive me, but if you are dying you will do everything you possibly can to put off the end, to buy yourself some more time for a little while longer, and many firms have bid for duty contracts because it buys them more time, notwithstanding the economics, notwithstanding the absurdity of the scheme, notwithstanding the potential fallout, they know that two or three firms in their area, or just outside their area have bid so they bid.   They have staff to pay and many, many other expenses.

The CLSA and the LCCSA hope that the last few weeks engagement with the MOJ  have demonstrated to the MOJ that if we work together in an  environment of trust then we can assist the MOJ in finding greater savings and efficiencies which do not require cuts. 

We believe that many of the ideas we have put forward will lead to savings and we are fully supportive of implementing both the recommendations in the Leveson review and the Jeffrey’s report.  There needs to be quality representation from the police station through to the Crown Court.  There needs to be far greater strategising between the leadership of the Bar and the solicitors in terms of the way forward. The survey on bid withdrawal may not be enough, we need to work with the bar in persuading the MOJ that Two Tier is a disaster for everyone. We need to consider what else that solicitors and the bar can do to oppose this model.  Arguments must be put forward concerning access to justice and the diversity of both sides of the profession so that criminal law does not become the preserve of bean counters or those whose families can subsidise their career choice

The bid survey is an excellent initiative which responds to the concerns of many members of the London Criminal Courts Solicitors Association, that there is no way that this system can work particularly given the shocking level of cuts which may all be operating by the time of the new contract.  Those members who have called for such a survey need to respond to it, and promote it.

  Recent meetings between us and the CBA leadership have been positive and we look forward to working with the new leadership team of Mark Fenhalls QC and Francis FitzGibbon QC and the junior bar of course in taking these matters forward together.

The exchanges with the Ministry of Justice and indeed the Lord Chancellor have been constructive.  This week we will find out how constructive.   Regardless of what, if anything, we are offered there needs to be greater acknowledgement on all sides (particularly the MOJ)   that sitting round a table is a far better way forward.

However, assuming that the Lord Chancellor does not want the non relationship with solicitors his predecessor had, these are a crucial few days for the MOJ.  Suggestions by solicitors have been made in good faith.   Now it is time to see whether there is any real give and take.  

It may be that the action can be temporarily suspended to acknowledge whatever offer is made provided there is ongoing engagement

It is definite that we can find the savings that the Ministry of Justice need as opposed to cuts, but it is time for them to simply decide whether they want to work with us or work against us, and ultimately if it’s with us Two Tier  must go.

 

Monday, 6 July 2015

The Tuesday Truth

by Zoe Gascoyne and Paul Harris


It is just under a week since many criminal lawyers across the country began their action against the 1st July fee cuts.

A keen observer of social media could be forgiven for confusing the announcements by different cities of support with the scoring section at the Eurovision Song Contest or perhaps more appropriately General Election night.

Merseyside in: Manchester in: Hull in: London in: Leeds in: Bradford in: Bristol in... and on it goes

There has suddenly been a sea change in the response by many firms. They now realise that they have no choice, these cuts will finish them and of course more importantly substantially restrict access to justice.

Solicitors and barristers together stand up for the vulnerable, for the wrongly accused, for those persecuted and harassed by state authorities.

They have so much more in common than divides them; their input together is worth so much more than in isolation. As the Junior Bar realised what was at stake they and many senior barristers have started to make their feelings known. Over the past few days   we have seen many declaring their support against the cuts that they know will be the end of them. This week already has seen an impressive roll call of chambers keen to support their professional colleagues;

Exchange Chambers: 9 St Johns: Kenworthy, Lincoln House, Garden Court, 25 Bedford Row, Mansfield Chambers  and many others

Even though the protest is only 6 days old the resolve and determination of those involved is growing. It will not be long before the Crown Courts are full of unrepresented defendants clogging up the lists causing greater public expense. A picture that will be indicative of the future of Gove's criminal justice system where access to justice is restricted.

These are sad and difficult times, no lawyer feels comfortable about clients being unrepresented, but they recognize that unless such action is taken the long term position for those caught up in the criminal justice system will be much worse. Cut price lawyers only able to deliver cut price representation leading to injustice for those most vulnerable.

Mr Gove says that the rule of law is the most precious asset of any country, but his actions and those that precede him tell a different story. He talks justice but seemingly has no intention of delivering.

We want to work with the Ministry on improving efficiencies and welcome the proposals of the Leveson report which places great emphasis on early ownership of cases and early engagement responsibilities which fall to Solicitors. They need to be properly funded to deliver such recommendations which ultimately may well deliver savings for all , the defence, the crown, the Court Service.

Today’s Monday Message was a further plea by Tony Cross, chairman of the CBA to encourage his members not to vote to join the action. He rehearses many of the arguments that he has rolled out before, the majority of which appear to have been rejected by his members who appear to be moving in favour of action including his own chambers.

Over the last few days we have seen a sad pattern developing and one would be forgiven for thinking that Solicitors are fighting a battle on two fronts; the MOJ and the CBA/ Senior Bar. In particular Twitter has been home to some desperate attempts by Senior QC's to undermine the unity of solicitors themselves and also the Junior Bar. Interestingly although they are keen to ask questions they are not so keen to tell us what it is they are seeking to protect. Those attempts have been designed to undermine the leaders of the CLSA and LCCSA and pose numerous questions all designed to try and create division. The simple fact of the matter is that there is no ulterior motive for solicitors. We are not interested in preserving one side of the profession and hanging the other out to dry. We want access to justice. We want a profession to be proud of. We want to preserve a quality independent bar properly funded together with properly funded solicitors. This has always been our position.

It appears that there is still a limited understanding of our position by some barristers and so we make a final attempt to clarify the situation in the simplest possible form;

Two Tier

1)   Many firms contract only with LAA therefore this is their sole source of income

2)    Many firms heavily rely on work generated through the duty solicitor schemes and therefore cannot afford not to have duty.

3)    Two tier is unpopular with the vast majority as demonstrated by 2 judicial reviews

4)    The tender timetable was accelerated and the majority felt they had a gun to their head so felt forced to tender (no contingency plan and facing huge financial ruin) Tender submissions do not guarantee contract. The offer of a contract does not mean you have to take it; the tender just gives you the option.

5)    The cuts were originally to be carried out in two stages because Grayling accepted the "market" couldn't cope with 17.5% and he needed consolidation to help absorb the second cut - the ONLY reason for consolidation was to enable the second cut.

6)    The first 8.75%  cut happened in March 2014. We were led to believe that the second cut would take place only after consolidation (two tier) and review (Leveson).

7)    Two tier was not what the MOJ had hoped, there were less applications than expected and some areas were not covered.
Leveson's review is helpful and says don't cut legal aid, but focusses on early engagement, IT and finding savings elsewhere.

8)    Gove was appointed Lord Chancellor. He had one short meeting with Solicitors and after just 4 four weeks in post he decides to cut anyway, ignoring Leveson and the evidence of the risk of market collapse.

9)    The decision was possibly made because two tier is unlikely to succeed and he needs the profession to self-consolidate.The second cut was announced on 10/06/15 to be implemented on 01/07/15 with further substantial  cuts in January 2016.

10)    The simple fact is CUTS ARE URGENT.
The cuts are the uniting factor.

11)    Two tier can wait, it will either;
a) be academic because it was only to be introduced to get the second cut in.
b) be unachievable because of quality and low number of tenders or
c) the profession (with new found strength and unity) will withdraw bids or decline contracts.

Cuts are the one thing that individual firms are addressing through action.
The simple fact is if that if cuts were reversed we wouldn't need indefinite action for two tier because we have proven ability to take a stand and there are other ways of dealing with two tier as above.

As far as the Bar is concerned we would like your support. We are grateful to the many barristers and chambers who have joined forces with us. We need to fight this together, but  we will fight with  or without you. We would rather stand as a united profession and we trust that you now understand our position.
The bottom line is you choose to fight for survival of the profession or you allow it to die through apathy. This is a decision for both solicitors and barristers. That decision will not wait.

Tuesday, 30 June 2015

The Tuesday Truth


Its 8.45pm on Tuesday 30th June 2015. There is barely any of Tuesday left so not much time for any Tuesday Truth

Tomorrow the Legal Aid Practitioners Group celebrates their Legal aid Lawyer of the Year award 2015. I went last year and recognised that at a time of great despair for legal aid practitioners and their clients this was one night to celebrate what was good about legal aid, to acknowledge the many vulnerable people that legal aid helped, to applaud those practitioners both solicitors and barristers who gave up their time for modest recompense to fight for the underdog.

Tomorrow night I am honoured to be receiving a special achievement award with Bill Waddington, Robin Murray and Jon Black for defending legal aid. We accept this award on behalf of everyone who has volunteered to fight the atrocious government attack on access to justice. There have been many people who have given up their time and this battle has gone on not for weeks/ months but years. We have been nominated by some of those people and we have worked with incredibly talented individuals on our committees.

However on the one day when legal aid is honoured, when we and many more deserving candidates are thanked for their tireless work the government will continue with their relentless attack on legal aid and access to justice.

The government will introduce another 8.75% cut to solicitor fees tomorrow, a further kick in the face for legal aid. 17.5% in just over a year with further cuts in January. Insufficient resources to protect those from state investigation

Finally many solicitors and barristers are saying no, this cannot go on and are refusing to work at the new rates.

There have been meetings all over the country which have seen solicitors and barristers’ two parts of the same profession unite to protect access to justice.

Michael Turner former Chair of the CBA said at a meeting at Garden Court chambers that this was not about the bar or solicitors it was about an attack on our justice system and of course we all share a responsibility to fight that.

Tomorrow and for the immediate period there may be widespread disruption around the country in the administration of justice. Solicitors and barristers take this action with a heavy heart, but the short term pain is sadly necessary for the long term gain of a proper robust justice system.

The meeting at Garden Court was well attended and had many valuable contributions from solicitors and barristers.

Many speeches began “I am not a radical but……….” In relation to protest action.

Greg Powell a former legal aid lawyer of the year began his remarks with “I am a radical and……..

Whether the speaker considered that they were a radical or not the message was the same, we cannot sit back and take this anymore.

So when you read this short Tuesday truth (it’s almost a Wednesday wander) I urge you to think about what we do , who benefits and whether you are a radical or not, as a lawyer advising yourself, you can see this is not about austerity, it’s about removing legal aid a fundamental right in an effective and fair democracy.

Monday, 22 June 2015

The Tuesday Truth


Written by Jon Black President of the LCCSA on behalf of the LCCSA and CLSA

And our ballot, sorry survey, sorry purely non- advisory response of random people not creating anything like a consensus says….It’s the same battle 

Reading this week’s Monday message from the CBA, you could be forgiven for thinking the most significant threat to our failing justice system is the existence of Solicitor Advocates .  To many this obsession is like being irate about the pointing around your windows when your house is falling into a sink hole.

It appears to many to be a diversionary tactic when the CBA had a clear mandate to take action.  It yet again serves to help the government in dividing the profession.  It has been clear for some time that Mr Cross sees the solicitor advocate as a bigger threat to the bar than the current policy decisions of the Ministry of Justice. 

Moving the goalposts and other clichéd metaphors

When is a ballot not a ballot?  When the CBA decide they do not like the answer they get, it appears.  If you call a thing something else when it appears in front of you it confuses the rational order of naming things. “Look it’s a sheep !”  “But when we sent it out to graze, it was definitely a horse. It still looks like a horse, its brown and has long legs and sticky up ears and  is not woolly in any way. “   “ No, no,  you’re wrong its definitely a sheep. “  “Umm confusing. “

 It’s almost as if those who voted to discount the response on the CBA Executive were attempting to circumvent the democratic process in which 96% of those voting supported action by suggesting after the event that this was a ‘survey’ and not a ballot.  This did not seem to have been made clear before the result was known.  Had CBA members in March 2014 voted against the original deal would that ballot also have been called a survey after the event  ?  When is a mandate not a mandate?  When is it a sounding? A toe in the water?  A discussion document?   A sop?

We want a level playing field too but the pitch is being dug up

It is with sadness that we again need to respond to this issue and waste time addressing a point that we hoped was far behind us.  The LCCSA and CLSA have previously publicly embraced the recommendations of the Jeffreys Report and agree that training and education should be on the same terms for each part of the profession.  The LCCSA and CLSA have frequently suggested that this issue could be resolved through private discussion between the representative organisations, including the Law Society and the Bar Council.  The Bar has never taken us up on this offer and instead has chosen to discuss the issue with the MOJ who we are told “feel their pain”.  Given the brutal economics that department has unleashed on both sides of the profession lets see how far that professed empathy gets the Bar. In the zero sum game it’s leadership is now engaging in, the junior bar lose as much as the solicitors. 

What the justice system deserves, what our clients deserve, are the best advocates, irrespective of whether they are solicitors or barristers.  Solicitors understand the importance of instructing the appropriate advocate, it is their professional duty to do so.  There has of course been a significant increase in the amount of advocacy being conducted in house but that does not automatically mean that those advocates are not well qualified or experienced.  All lawyers want to win, if they don’t win enough then irrespective of whether they are solicitors or barristers the best professional training should be available.  Standards across the board should be raised.  The solicitors associations have been engaged in nearly three years of campaigning and litigating in a fight for survival, continuing advocacy training will be a priority but at present fighting for access to justice and for professional survival has had to come first.  

But what are solicitors prepared to do ?

It is a frequent gripe, not just from barristers, that we are not prepared to take action.  Consider this, we have tried to negotiate with the government; we have tried to reason by way of statistics and reports and when this failed the LCCSA and CLSA invested heavily in litigation to stop the two tier process.  As those who were present during the National Justice Committee meetings know it was the solicitors who wanted to call a date for direct action weeks before it happened but had to wait while the CBA and Circuit Leaders conferred and the stars aligned.

But the question being asked “What are solicitors prepared to do?” is a fair question although open to manipulation by those who do not want to confront the government.  We have picked up the gauntlet and are asking our members if they would be willing to refuse work at the new rates and support a return to no returns.

The CBA should not underestimate the importance that the support of solicitors meant to the effectiveness of the No Returns policy which the CBA claim has led them to the sunny uplands of “being left alone”  with an overall decline in work and no sign of fee rises. Hurrah!  The responsibility of calming angry clients when they arrived at court unrepresented was not a pleasant one, but we stood by the Bar. There were a renegade few firms who did otherwise but like turkeys opting for bread sauce rather than cranberry their lack of unity has not improved their survival prospects. Indeed there were also barrister chambers in some regions of the country who did not support the CBA policy on No Returns.   

At the height of the Bar’s greatest negotiating strength many think the leadership disastrously surrendered the advantage obtained through the determination and sacrifice of masses of juniors up and down the country and like turkeys voting for the slow roast, non fan option settled for an agreement that there would be no direct action so long as the bar was left uncut.  

Two months before, the then CBA chair had publicly resolved to negotiate jointly with solicitors. https://www.criminalbar.com/latest-updates/news/q/date/2014/01/20/monday-message-20-01-14/

 To suggest we are suffering from ‘blinkered prejudice’ which leads us to be mistrustful is patronising and wrong.  We are asked why are we cautious and perhaps cynical as to how far the CBA can make progress with the MOJ?  It is because it is clear that these further cuts were always planned , that they ultimately harm the bar as much as the solicitors and that no amount of deal making in the manner  that took place last year and in the last few days would have changed that.  

But why did some of you bid ?

The CBA leadership has constantly looked for reasons not to unite with us, citing reasons such as the (limited) number of firms which did not support and participate in No Returns and the fact that after the loss of our Appeal, firms submitted bids. Barristers are self employed,  in itself a precarious and exposed position, they have responsibilities to their families and to colleagues in chambers with regards to rent but what many fail to understand is the huge burden on the small business owner not only struggling to keep what for many is their life’s work afloat but also immediately responsible for the employment of a raft of people , who has continual demands in terms of monthly salaries, topping up pension contributions and servicing loans never mind supporting their own families and paying the mortgage . The collapse of a law firm is swift and shocking but its aftermath is painful and protracted as many articles in the Law Society Gazette demonstrate. Bidding for nearly all of those who did was done through gritted teeth with enormous reluctance.  It was an agonising, dispiriting process but it was either quick and messy business death or a few more months of grinding out an existence in the hope that survival was possible.  Of course let us not forget the bar entities that are understood to have submitted bids as well.

So what has taken place behind the scenes?  I  was invited to meet Michael Gove with four other colleagues at the end of May.  The new Lord Chancellor had been in post for two and a half weeks, we understood he had only recently been briefed as to our concerns regarding closure of firms and access to justice. We spent most of the meeting explaining why the Two Tier scheme needed to be reconsidered. Although he was particularly interested to hear how our clients will be affected, he said that notwithstanding our concerns it may be difficult to end dual contracting at this stage, the ship having already left the harbour. The Titanic comes to mind. Mr Vara, the Legal Aid minister also in attendance,  hinted that they were focussing on ensuring that quality of advocacy was not impacted , which we can take to mean that the quality of litigation is for some reason not a priority.

We then heard nothing until 9th June, we now learn this was the date of the MOJ’s second meeting with the CBA post election.   I know it is often said we mustn't look back at the past but like all history lessons it helps us to understand where we are now and how we can learn from what has happened before. We had been promised in the aftermath of the disastrous deal in March 2014 and again in the Consultation documents, that a review on fee cuts would be undertaken in conjunction with a review into advocacy fees.    The Transforming Legal Aid document announced a cut to AGFs alongside the staged cut to solicitors’ fees. The 27th November response once again made reference to the cut in solicitors’ fees subject to review, but now no mention of the AGFS cut It appeared to have disappeared into the ether. On further enquiry we were told that in fact there was to be a review of AGFs , the criteria being based on crime spend and the Leveson Report  , whereas the solicitors'  cut would take into account Leveson and the impact of the first cut . 


(para 3.4)

Hugh Barrett head of Legal Aid at the MOJ told us in April that the second cut would be subject to a review after the General Election . So when did that review take place? In the 19 days before we met Mr Gove on 9th June ? If so why didn't he say so? In the 7 working days after our meeting? Or the five working days between the CLSA document sent on 2nd June setting out alternative savings?

Curious, it’s almost as if there wasn’t a proper review and perhaps no real intention of having one. We have been here before in the procedurally flawed consultation. The MOJ approach to the profession now seems to have been erased from the CBA leadership’s collective memory..            

The MOJ is blithely ignorant of the fact that if you properly fund those  who are committed to their clients , who prepare and litigate fearlessly and with intelligence , persistence and skill  then the advocate is in the best possible position to advance the lay clients case. Advocates and co defending solicitors alike have had their jobs made harder by the decline in standards across the board since savage budget cuts to the CPS , to the Courts Service and the introduction of LGFs heralded the ‘stack em high sell em cheap’ mentality which prevails at the MOJ and LAA at a time when we now learn that the head honchos are lavishly rewarded for presiding over a crumbling justice system.

With the grim reality of the second fee cut and the fee restructuring to come in January 2016 has come the realisation that the government has nothing but contempt for the whole profession and is entirely reckless as to the sustainability of criminal defence never mind any pretensions to guarantees of quality.  As a result we have reached last chance saloon and there are now a significant number of big firms indicating that they are in favour of refusing to accept new work after 1st July.

It has been suggested that the CBA cannot or will not support solicitors because our ballot appears to be about the rates not Duty Contracts.   However, a boycott of new work disrupts the duty scheme creating a backlog which would stretch into January. Furthermore, may we remind Mr Cross of the pledge that he was keen for solicitors to sign in 2013, on exactly this point, namely that solicitors could not carry out their professional duties at the new rates . What has changed? A cosier relationship with the Lord Chancellor?

The purpose of historical reminder is not to perpetuate division, but to demonstrate that what has gone on here has not only been divisive but contrary to the interests of both professions. We need to build a new generation of trust. It is against our joint interests to continue on divergent paths and to allow solicitors to suffer such devastating cuts.

Those thousands at the bar who passionately  believe in the rule of law and access to justice will, we hope, join with solicitors in making it clear to this Lord Chancellor that we will fight together to withstand his attempts to destroy the provision of legally  aided  representation.

The CBA leadership claim to want a ‘level playing field’ but they are simply talking about the players on their team.  We are not asking barristers to fight ‘the solicitor’s battle for us’.  We are asking barristers to fight the war of attrition we must win to preserve our criminal justice system and with it the rule of law.   

Monday, 15 June 2015

The Tuesday Truth

Criminal Solicitors: An endangered Species

The statement from the Legal Aid Minister last Wednesday 10th June 2015 makes no mention of my profession…….a solicitor.

It refers to maintaining high standards of advocacy but does not mention the quality representation provided by Solicitors in the main in the Magistrates Court where all criminal cases are heard at some stage. It also does not consider the difficult job done by solicitors at the police station, often the most significant part of any criminal case.

 The statement does refer to litigators and I suspect that Mr Vara does not care whether the litigator is an experienced Solicitor or legal executive, a paralegal or someone just out of school.

The sexy public side of criminal defence is performed in the Crown Courts by Higher Court Advocates, the majority of which are from the Independent Bar (currently). It is those wigs and gowns which everyone recognises.  This is why when those wigs and gowns were outside the court protesting and not inside the government knew they had a problem and had to do a deal.

Mr Vara knows it is that image he needs to avoid and so there is his public flirtation with the bar

The implementation of no returns last year proved to be a huge problem for the government. There were cases in Crown Court's across the land that simply couldn't be covered. Don't get me wrong they did their best and called in every PDS Advocate they could to traipse across the country covering cases.  In one case a QC was called into cover a trial at Liverpool Crown Court that wasn't a case for a Silk and at what cost to the public? The fact is the government need the Bar on side to force consolidation upon solicitors and inflict in excess of 17.5% cuts to our fees. They are determined to make their savings at whatever the cost and so in a nod to the Bar once again we see the AGFS protected. Clever tactics Mr Vara and Mr Gove might think but those of us in practice know better. In protecting the AGFS they are ring fencing an area of work which solicitors will have no choice but to try and capitalise upon. Whether they do this by way of Solicitor Advocates or by way of employing in-house Counsel they will be forced to do it to make up for the savage cuts that they are about to sustain.

Whilst the Solicitors receive this cut in the name of "austerity" after 20 years of cut after cut it is even more disappointing to learn that the Chief Executive of the Legal Aid Agency has received a £20,000 pay rise to take his salary to £225,000, a reward perhaps for reducing scope, access to justice and state accountability. Those that deliver this work at the coalface , who try to protect the vulnerable face cuts to subsidise those who implement policies which may lead to more litigants in person, more advice deserts and the meltdown of a justice system. Something does not seem right here!

 Their initial premise was cuts of 17.5% in exchange for consolidation. We  saw an 8.75% cut in March last year with no consolidation. That first cut has already seen some firms go out of business and many make staff redundant.  We are now about to get the second one for 6 months also without consolidation. Their promise of a review after the cuts and reform ( ie shoot first and ask questions after) is lamentable. If they had any true concerns they could conduct a pilot. They haven't and they won't.

You might ask yourself why it is that Gove has decided to implement the cut before consolidation. Grayling and the MoJ have always openly acknowledged that that the current supplier base couldn't sustain the second cut without consolidation. What's changed? Two tier is underway they have their time table and they have their tenders. Is there a sudden requirement to save £X by the 31st of August or is it that they now realise that two tier isn't going to work. That would be the perfect reason to change the course of their plans. Two tier is about to become a spectacularly embarrassing failure, not good when the profession have been telling them it would be for two years. Gove however is a shrewd man and sees that there is opportunity to force consolidation through the back door. Impose the second half of the 17.5% cut and allow survival of the fittest. Those who can survive the cut might see an increase in volume from the firms forced to close, of which there will be many. Great job by Gove, he even gets to announce in a few months that having listened to the profession he has decided not to press ahead with two tier - the perfect cover up. Not convinced? Ok so they implement the second cut because you don't do anything about it. You choose not to protest because your firm was ok with the two tier, you wanted the increase in volume. The reality is you only wanted the increase in volume because you knew you couldn't sustain the second cut without it. You have problems now. You submitted your tender, you don't know the outcome and yet you now face at least six months operating at a further 8.75% less with no increase in volume. That's a big problem for cash flow. Your firm needs to make it through six months hoping to get a contract. Are we not now at the point where the work is not worth doing, if not now, when will it be, at a 20% cut, or 25%?

Whichever way you look at it as a profession we've been shafted. We dared to challenge them twice in court, unforgiveable!!!.   Criminal lawyers were not rushing to the polls ticking the conservative box. They know that in the main the bar are visible side of criminal justice, keep them happy, no one needs to know what is going on behind the scenes.

They thrive on our lack of unity, there are always firms somewhere who will see an opportunity, “we will take the cut because we will have much more work”. These firms need to wake up. This is the beginning of a 5 year term for this government and legal aid is not a vote winner. Those who survive this cut and the duty contracts tender(if indeed it ever comes to fruition), will be in the firing line for the next cut and the next reform which is likely to come in the next 5 years. I saw on Facebook that Dominic Grieve said that they came for us because we were a target of little resistance and this of course is common sense. They need to make savings; solicitors make a noise but never cause a problem so they will simply keep going. Grayling always made it clear that two tier was only part one of his plan. Once they have 527 firms in place it becomes a more manageable task to get the larger organisations such as G4S, Serco and Capita on board. After all this is what this government do best, sub-contract to large companies regardless of their capabilities. If this doesn't concern you then it should. Yes you might be "fortunate" enough to get a contract but what's going to happen to you in four years time when they start the process again. You'll do something about it then right? Wrong, there'll be no support from the public and less of us to provide support. There's also every chance they'll continue to extend the PDS which will put to bed any ideas of a protest. 

There will always be someone who will turn up at the Magistrates Court or the police station; there will always be someone who will provide the cover and the MOJ know that.

And if anyone dares object they will send out those contract notices, I mean the contracts themselves with their numerous extensions are probably unlawful but after all it’s the Ministry of “Justice”, so we have to play by their flexible rules.

It’s an inappropriate analogy but sometimes solicitors who get great pride in protecting the interests of their clients through passionate advocacy ironically are like the abused partner in a domestic relationship and they simply go back for more and more, just taking it, time after time. They will stop sometime! I don’t think so.

The bottom line is that in the end we will have substandard justice system where those accused of offences will have defence teams lacking the proper resources to do the job. The vulnerable, the young and the mentally ill will be even more compromised when caught up in this system.

I personally have been patronized by the Justice Ministers and civil servants enough. I sat with a few others in a meeting a few weeks ago with Mr Gove, Vara and various civil servants Mr Gove was polite, charming and appeared engaged, but with a very insincere “Hmmm” which he deployed far too often as he pretended to be really interested.

He said that would welcome other suggestions for savings they could make to the legal aid system which upon reflection seems analogous to throwing him next week’s winning lottery numbers from the Titanic.

 

The LCCSA and the CLSA have set up a hub, please log in.


The bar recognize that Vara’s flirting is nothing more than a tease and the preservation of their fees will mean nothing if there is no work.

The MOJ make up the rules as they go along, they do not care if the duty solicitor tender works or not, they will patch something together, after all it's only now that they accept there may have been overcrowding in prisons, they will move the goal posts whenever they see fit.
Isn’t it time for us to start making the rules, if not for us but the people we act for and for the integrity of a robust justice system not just on the surface. If you agree that the time has come to make a stand then rest assured there are many willing to stand shoulder to shoulder with you, from both sides of the profession